Vintage Costume Jewelry

Vintage Costume Jewelry

454 products

  • Featured
  • Most relevant
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old

Filter by

    • In stock (272)
    • Out of stock (182)
Icy Rhinestone Flower Screw Back Earrings

Icy Rhinestone Flower Screw-Back Earrings
$ 65.00
$ 65.00
Sold Out
Double Strand of Baby Blue Aurora Borealis Finish Beads

Double Strand of Baby Blue Aurora Borealis Finish Beads
$ 95.00
$ 95.00
Sold Out
Funky Venetian Glass Bead Earrings

Funky Venetian Glass Bead Earrings
$ 78.00
$ 78.00
Sold Out
Pink & Green Rose Enameled Circle Brooch

Pink & Green Rose Enameled Circle Brooch
$ 68.00
$ 68.00
Sold Out
Bold Flourish Black & Gold Costume Brooch

Bold Flourish Black & Gold Costume Brooch
$ 68.00
$ 68.00
Sold Out
Sporty Black & White Rhinestone Golf Pin

Sporty Black & White Rhinestone Golf Pin
$ 52.00
$ 52.00
Sold Out
Spectacular Asymmetric Rhinestone Clip On Earrings

Spectacular Asymmetric Rhinestone Clip On Earrings
$ 98.00
$ 98.00
Sold Out
Dynamic Red Rhinestone Dome Costume Earrings

Dynamic Red Rhinestone Dome Costume Earrings
$ 85.00
$ 85.00
Sold Out
Double Headed Arrow Modernist Brooch in Silver Plate

Double Headed Arrow Modernist Brooch in Silver Plate
$ 195.00
$ 195.00
Sold Out

Glamorous Rhinestone & Crystal Earrings by Eisenberg
$ 145.00
$ 145.00
Sold Out
Abstract Nosegay Brooch in AB Rhinestones

Abstract Nosegay Brooch in AB Rhinestones
$ 125.00
$ 125.00
Sold Out
Vivacious White Rhinestone Swirl Brooch

Vivacious White Rhinestone Swirl Brooch
$ 110.00
$ 110.00
Sold Out
Colorful Watermelon Rhinestone Oval Brooch

Colorful Watermelon Rhinestone Oval Brooch
$ 75.00
$ 75.00
Sold Out
Fun Mod Costume Earrings from Goldette

Fun Mod Costume Earrings from Goldette
$ 52.00
$ 52.00
Sold Out
Chunky Modernist Sculptural Lucite Brooch

Chunky Modernist Sculptural Lucite Brooch
$ 95.00
$ 95.00
Sold Out
Two Triangles Brass Brooch by Peggy Miller

Two Triangles Brass Brooch by Peggy Miller
$ 195.00
$ 195.00
Sold Out
Pretty Pastel Pink Glass Leaf Jomaz Earrings

Pretty Pastel Pink Glass Leaf Jomaz Earrings
$ 125.00
$ 125.00
Sold Out
Miriam Haskell Brass Filigree Flower Brooch

Miriam Haskell Brass Filigree Flower Brooch
$ 195.00
$ 195.00
Sold Out
Fresh Spring Nosegay Brooch in Enamel & Rhinestones

Fresh Spring Nosegay Brooch in Enamel & Rhinestones
$ 195.00
$ 195.00
Sold Out
atomic cufflink and tie pin set

Atomic 1960s Cufflink & Tie Pin Set
$ 95.00
$ 95.00
Sold Out
West German Black & White Glass Dangle Earrings

West German Black & White Glass Dangle Earrings
$ 85.00
$ 85.00
Sold Out
Lovely Long Autumnal Glass Bead Necklace

Lovely Long Autumnal Glass Bead Necklace
$ 120.00
$ 120.00
Sold Out
Victorian English Moulded Black Glass Beads

Victorian English Moulded Black Glass Beads
$ 125.00
$ 125.00
Sold Out

The Gems may be Faux but the Sparkle is Real. Renoir, Matisse, Trifari, Coro, Jomaz, Mazer. All the collectible Costume Jewelry names you know and love.

Costume Jewelry FAQ

Is costume jewelry the same as "fake jewelry"?

Not exactly. Many people say "fake jewelry" when they mean costume jewelry—beautiful designs made with non-precious materials. Our vintage pieces are well-crafted, collectible, and full of character.

Does costume jewelry tarnish or turn skin green?

Quality vintage costume jewelry holds up well with care. Avoid water, lotions, and perfume; store pieces dry; and buff gently after wear.

How can I tell costume jewelry from fine jewelry?

Look for materials and hallmarks. Costume pieces often use plated metals, glass, or rhinestones; fine jewelry uses solid precious metals and gemstones. When in doubt, ask our team.

What is the price range for vintage costume jewelry?

Prices vary by maker, materials, condition, and rarity. Many pieces from the 1960s–1980s start around $40–$150, while signed or highly collectible designs (e.g., Weiss, Trifari, Miriam Haskell) can range from $200–$800 or more. Exceptional or rare pieces can reach into the thousands.