Vintage Costume Jewelry

Vintage Costume Jewelry

431 products

  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old

Filter by

    • In stock (281)
    • Out of stock (150)
Rhinestone Paved Celluloid Clamper Bracelet & Earrings

Rhinestone Paved Celluloid Clamper Bracelet & Earrings
$ 295.00
$ 295.00
Sold Out
Handsome Horse Head Bakelite Brooch

Handsome Horse Head Bakelite Brooch
$ 495.00
$ 495.00
Sold Out
Ghost Bangle Clear Lucite Bracelet

Ghost Bangle Clear Lucite Bracelet
$ 165.00
$ 165.00
Sold Out

Funky Mid-Century Butterscotch Bakelite Bangle
$ 195.00
$ 195.00
Sold Out
Plastic Fantastic Poison Green Lucite Bangle

Plastic Fantastic Poison Green Lucite Bangle
$ 195.00
$ 195.00
Sold Out
Autumn Leaves Apple Juice Bakelite Bangle

Autumn Leaves Apple Juice Bakelite Bangle
$ 325.00
$ 325.00
Sold Out
Tropical Motif Carved Black Bakelite Bangle

Tropical Motif Carved Black Bakelite Bangle
$ 395.00
$ 395.00
Sold Out
Eisenberg Baby Blues Swarovski Crystal Bracelet

Eisenberg Baby Blues Swarovski Crystal Bracelet
$ 265.00
$ 265.00
Sold Out
Unusual Crystal Chandelier Earrings by Eisenberg

Unusual Crystal Chandelier Earrings by Eisenberg
$ 195.00
$ 195.00
Sold Out
Tiered Sterling & Crystal Eisenberg Original Brooch

Tiered Sterling & Crystal Eisenberg Original Brooch
$ 495.00
$ 495.00
Sold Out
Fabulous Eisenberg Original Sterling & Crystal Dress Clip

Fabulous Eisenberg Original Sterling & Crystal Dress Clip
$ 595.00
$ 595.00
Sold Out
Bluebell Nosegay Brooch by Eisenberg

Bluebell Nosegay Brooch by Eisenberg
$ 225.00
$ 225.00
Sold Out
Effervescent Crystal Cluster Necklace by Eisenberg

Effervescent Crystal Cluster Necklace by Eisenberg
$ 295.00
$ 295.00
Sold Out
Pert Sterling & Crystal Bow from Eisenberg Originals

Pert Sterling & Crystal Bow from Eisenberg Originals
$ 495.00
$ 495.00
Sold Out
Spectacular Eisenberg Shoulder Duster Crystal Earrings

Spectacular Eisenberg Shoulder Duster Crystal Earrings
$ 325.00
$ 325.00
Sold Out
Eisenberg Original Crystal & Sterling Silver Brooch

Eisenberg Original Crystal & Sterling Silver Brooch
$ 245.00
$ 245.00
Sold Out
Meso-American Mask Eisenberg Original Brooch

Meso-American Mask Eisenberg Original Brooch
$ 195.00
$ 195.00
Sold Out
Darling Pink & Blue Dress Clip by Eisenberg

Darling Pink & Blue Eisenberg Original Dress Clip
$ 395.00
$ 395.00
Sold Out
Sparkling Two Row Crystal Bracelet by Eisenberg

Sparkling Two Row Crystal Bracelet by Eisenberg
$ 225.00
$ 225.00
Sold Out
Lovely Lilac Eisenberg Ice Necklace & Earring Set

Lovely Lilac Eisenberg Ice Necklace & Earring Set
$ 295.00
$ 295.00
Sold Out
Bountiful Eisenberg Original Crystal & Sterling Bow Brooch

Bountiful Eisenberg Original Crystal & Sterling Bow Brooch
$ 395.00
$ 395.00
Sold Out
Round Eisenberg Swarovski Crystal Brooch

Round Eisenberg Swarovski Crystal Brooch
$ 185.00
$ 185.00
Sold Out
Captivating Feather Motif Eisenberg Ice Brooch

Captivating Feather Motif Eisenberg Ice Brooch
$ 165.00
$ 165.00
Sold Out
Round & Emerald Cut Crystal Eisenberg Bracelet

Round & Emerald Cut Crystal Eisenberg Bracelet
$ 225.00
$ 225.00
Sold Out
Juicy Pearl Cut Crystals in Dazzling Eisenberg Brooch

Juicy Pear-Cut Crystals in Dazzling Eisenberg Brooch
$ 245.00
$ 245.00
Sold Out
Exuberant Eisenberg Ice Crystal Corsage Brooch

Exuberant Eisenberg Ice Crystal Corsage Brooch
$ 175.00
$ 175.00
Sold Out
Fabulous Eisenberg Brooch with Watermelon Crystals

Fabulous Eisenberg Brooch with Watermelon Crystals
$ 195.00
$ 195.00
Sold Out
Brilliant Swarovski Crystal Bracelet Signed Eisenberg

Brilliant Swarovski Crystal Bracelet Signed Eisenberg
$ 195.00
$ 195.00
Sold Out
Fabulous Oversized Corsage Brooch by Hagler N.Y.C.

Fabulous Oversized Corsage Brooch by Hagler N.Y.C.
$ 495.00
$ 495.00
Sold Out
Copper & White Enamel Bracelet Signed Matisse

Copper with Black & White Enamel Bracelet Signed Matisse
$ 72.00
$ 72.00
Sold Out
Sculptural Mid Century Gold-Tone Cufflinks

Sculptural Mid-Century Gold-Tone Cufflinks
$ 85.00
$ 85.00
Sold Out

The Gems may be Faux but the Sparkle is Real. Renoir, Matisse, Trifari, Coro, Jomaz, Mazer. All the collectible Costume Jewelry names you know and love.

Costume Jewelry FAQ

Is costume jewelry the same as "fake jewelry"?

Not exactly. Many people say "fake jewelry" when they mean costume jewelry—beautiful designs made with non-precious materials. Our vintage pieces are well-crafted, collectible, and full of character.

Does costume jewelry tarnish or turn skin green?

Quality vintage costume jewelry holds up well with care. Avoid water, lotions, and perfume; store pieces dry; and buff gently after wear.

How can I tell costume jewelry from fine jewelry?

Look for materials and hallmarks. Costume pieces often use plated metals, glass, or rhinestones; fine jewelry uses solid precious metals and gemstones. When in doubt, ask our team.

What is the price range for vintage costume jewelry?

Prices vary by maker, materials, condition, and rarity. Many pieces from the 1960s–1980s start around $40–$150, while signed or highly collectible designs (e.g., Weiss, Trifari, Miriam Haskell) can range from $200–$800 or more. Exceptional or rare pieces can reach into the thousands.